Editorial Analysis || India’s wrong approach to paid maternity leave

Mains Paper: 1 | Women

Prelims level: Paid maternity leave, Labour force participation.

Mains level:  India is moving towards by the wrong approach to paid maternity leave.
Context:

———————————————

Bottom of Form

• A common concern for India and the US is the decline or stagnation in female labour force participation in recent decades.

• In the US, between 1960 and 2016, female labour force participation (LFP) increased from less than 40% to nearly 60%.

• Yet, since the 2000s, participation has tended to stagnate and even decline. It is a similar story in India.

• Not only have female LFP rates been lower than other comparable economies, the trend reveals declining rates over time.

• Research suggests that nearly 28% of the decline in female participation in the US relative to other Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development economies is due to its lack of family-friendly policies, such as paid parental leave.

• While India has had a maternity leave policy on the books since 1961, it recently expanded the law in 2017.

• Yet, there is increasing concern and speculation that the law may have the unintended consequence of worsening the labour market for women.

Does having a paid parental leave law lead to higher or lower female LFP?

• The working group has the advantage of having members who hold diverse political perspectives, enabling us to consider different viewpoints.

• This has allowed us to study not only the benefits of paid leave but also the costs associated with implementing the policies, especially on businesses.

• India’s maternity benefit amendment offers new mothers 26 weeks of paid leave from their workplace, with an average wage replacement rate of 100%.

• Having access to paid leave is critical for today’s families.

• Research on paid parental leave shows that there are both economic as well as health benefits to mothers and children when leave is easily available.

Present context of paid maternity bill

• In India, the policy is problematic because it is imposed as an employer mandate.

• Employers have to bear the entire cost of providing leave to employees—in terms of both continued pay while on leave, as well as the indirect cost of having to get the work done by employing other workers to finish the work of the absent employee.

• In turn, this raises the concern that employers will begin to discriminate against women of childbearing age, both in hiring as well as in salaries, since this group is entitled to the benefit of paid family leave and is most likely to use it.

• Therefore, employer mandates are not the ideal way to design a paid leave programme.

How the policy should be designed?

• The solution could lie in imposing the cost of the paid leave policy on employees through a tax.

• In other words, while employers would provide job-protected leave, the wage replacement could be funded through an employee payroll tax.

• The US, for instance, has a federal programme that guarantees job-protected unpaid leave of 12 weeks for new parents.

• Paid leave programmes, however, have come up in several states, such as California, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and, more recently, New York, Washington, DC, Massachusetts, and Washington. 

• Imposing the tax only on employees to minimize any additional costs on the employer when providing paid leave.

• Such programmes have worked well at the state level, where employers have reported feeling little or no administrative burdens from the paid leave programme.

• The design of such a policy is gender neutrality.

Conclusion

• The paid leave law in India covers only a small fraction of the workforce, given the growth of the informal economy.

• More should be done to improve access for low wage workers in the informal sector. 

• India gets right about the maternity leave law is that it is a federal law guaranteeing uniform access to paid leave to all eligible employees across the country.

• But there is much that can be improved about the design of the policy to ensure that it works well not only for workers but also businesses. 

Link: https://tt93a.app.goo.gl/APbvGL9FfJPX7bXH8