[Editorial Analysis] On overzealous reservation

Mains Paper 2:Polity
Prelims level: Scheduled Areas
Mains level: Reservations for STs in scheduled areas

Context:

• The Supreme Court is right in considering cent percent reservation as anathema to the constitutional scheme of equality even if it is for the laudable objective of providing representation to historically deprived sections.

Key highlights of the verdict:

• The verdict quashing the reservation of 100% of all teaching posts in ‘Scheduled Areas’ of Andhra Pradesh for local Scheduled Tribes is not against affirmative programs as such, but caution against implementing them in a manner detrimental to the rest of society.

• The Constitution Bench found that earmarking teacher posts in areas notified under the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution adversely affected the interests of other candidates not only from Scheduled Castes and other backward communities but also other ST communities not native to those areas.

• As the Bench noted, it could have come up with other incentives to ensure the attendance of teachers.

• Another aspect that the court took into account was that Andhra Pradesh has a local area system of recruitment to public services.

Chronic absenteeism:

• The State government did, in its original orders of 1986, and thereafter, in a subsequent order in 2000, was not without its own rationale.

• It found that there was chronic absenteeism among teachers who did not belong to those remote areas where the schools were located.

Viable solution:

• However, its solution of drafting only members of the local tribes was not a viable solution.

• The President, under Article 371D, has issued orders that a resident of a district/zone cannot apply to another district/zone for an appointment.

• Thus, the 100% quota deprived residents of the Scheduled Areas of any opportunity to apply for teaching posts.

• Affirmative action loses its meaning if it does not leave the door slightly ajar for open competition.

• Dr. B.R. Ambedkar observed during the debate in the Constituent Assembly on the equality clause, that any reservation normally ought to be for a “minority of seats”. This is one of the points often urged in favor of the 50% cap imposed by the Court on the total reservation, albeit with some allowance for relaxation in special circumstances.

Criticism:

• It is still a matter of debate whether the ceiling has innate sanctity, but it is clear that wherever it is imperative that the cap is breached, a special case must be made for it.

• Such a debate should not divert attention from the fact that there is a continuing need for a significant quota for STs, especially those living in areas under the Fifth Schedule special dispensation.

• In this backdrop, it is somewhat disappointing that courts tend to record obiter dicta advocating a revision of the list of SCs
and STs.

Conclusion:

• While the power to amend the lists notified by the President is not in dispute, it is somewhat uncharitable to say that the advanced and “affluent” sections within SCs and STs are cornering all benefits and do not permit any trickle-down.

• Indian society is still some distance from reaching that point.

———————————————

Prelims Questions:

Q.1) With reference to the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), consider the following statements:

1. It was established under Article 323 – B of the Constitution.

2. The Tribunal is guided by the principles of natural justice in deciding cases and is not bound by the procedure, prescribed by the Civil Procedure Code.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) Both 1 and 2
(d) Neither 1 nor 2

Answer: B

Mains Questions:

Q.1) To what extend the 100 percent reservations given to the Scheduled tribes in Andhra Pradesh tend to affect rights of other communities. Critically examine.

Subscribe to Get Weekly updates

Get daily current affair video, detailed current affairs PPT for quick revision and Free One Liner PDF directly in your inbox. Subscribe now to get this month's one liner for FREE.